Home / Opinion / Super caps: Keep calm and carry on (for now)

Super caps: Keep calm and carry on (for now)

The Treasurer's plan to limit concessional tax treatment within super at $3M comes without a lot of the details required for effective retirement planning. Making bold changes now could be costly, says Wattle Partners principal Drew Meredith.
Opinion

Last week the Federal Government announced a major change to the taxation of superannuation assets. Importantly, this remains proposed and is unlikely to be legislated for at least 12 months.

Under the proposal, the balance of an individual’s member account within a superannuation fund, whether that is an SMSF, platform or industry super fund, will be subject to additional taxation.

Specifically, the earnings on the balance of an individual’s super account that exceeds $3 million will be taxed at an additional 15 per cent.

  • This will apply in addition to the current taxation rates that apply, being 15 per cent on those assets held in accumulation phase, and 0 per cent for those in pension phase.

    Importantly, this is calculated per member balance, or per person, rather than for an entire fund with the government suggesting less than 80,000 people will be impacted today.

    We have two key concerns with the proposal.

    The first is that the earnings that will be taxed at an additional 15 per cent will be calculated based on the notional or unrealised value of your member balance. That is, if the value of your super fund increases during a financial year, you will be taxed on the increase in the value, whether it is realised via the sale of assets or not.

    This sort of taxation does not apply in any other part of the taxation system, hence we do not believe it is likely to be passed in its current form on this basis.

    Similarly, the $3 million cap will not be indexed, hence a significantly higher number of people will likely be impacted by it in the future as balances continue to grow and inflation reduces the value of capital.

    As retirement and superannuation specialists, we are concerned about the constant tinkering with superannuation and taxation legislation. That said, despite the proposed changes superannuation will remain by far the most tax effective entity structure through which to hold your retirement assets.

    As the proposal works its way through the legislative process, however, and the picture becomes more certain, alternative options to maximise tax efficiency will become clearer. These may include family trusts, adding money to the superannuation balance of children, adding members to an SMSF or even setting up a corporate beneficiary.

    At this stage, and until the amendments are made clear in their ultimate form, the important thing for retirees who may be affected is to remain calm and refrain from making any drastic financial changes. As ever, with superannuation, the devil will be in the detail.

    Drew Meredith

    Drew is publisher of the Inside Network's mastheads and a principal adviser at Wattle Partners.




    Print Article

    Related
    ‘Not talented enough’: Vanguard indulges in hubris as active equity managers slide

    As the biggest ETF provider in Australia, Vanguard has the right to crow about another knockout performance over active equity. But invective commentary is a red flag, especially when it’s based on something as changeable as recent market performance.

    Tahn Sharpe | 14th Nov 2024 | More
    Investment paradigm shifts as portfolio positioning overtakes performance

    With markets at all-time highs and term deposits paying 5 per cent, the focus needs to shift away from relative returns and back towards positioning for “consistent, absolute” returns that accommodate present market risks.

    Drew Meredith | 3rd Oct 2024 | More
    Dixon’s inquiry could be a reckoning for vertically integrated practices in advice

    In the Dixon’s inquiry vertical integration will not only be writ large, but it will have thousands of victims’ names attached to it. The practice has run relatively unfettered for years, but that may be about to change.

    Tahn Sharpe | 19th Sep 2024 | More
    Popular
  • Popular posts: