Home / Alternatives / Is gold only for the true believers?

Is gold only for the true believers?


Gold’s crown is a little tainted by its recent price retracement, which has taken the yellow metal roughly back to where it was a year ago. Instead, Bitcoin has smashed the ball out of the park. Why is there such a difference between these two?

  • At an elementary level, both assets play to the concern that monetary policy is undermining the value of fiat currencies, and as an insurance against nefarious policies.  

    Gold has obviously been around for years. It is durable, incapable of destruction, and it is fungible, as gold is gold regardless of its presentation. It can be divided and is portable. Scarcity is a more vexed issue. There is a finite amount in the earth, with possible new deposits to be discovered. But there are many non-financial holders that could add to investment supply.  

    The predominant influence is, however, simply the belief in its value. History has repeated the role of gold for centuries, embedding its status in times of strife.

    Since the deregulation of major monetary systems from the gold standard in the 1960s and 1970s, the price has reflected either extreme events such as the oil price spike of the early 1980s or relative exchange rates. The key has been psychology.

    Many believe gold is a safe investment asset. It may be a physical good, but its price volatility would not align with other so-called low-volatility options.  

    Bitcoin has similar characteristics. Its favourite premise is to void government oversight or interference. The mathematical and energy complexities portray its scarcity, with the set limit yet to be tested. And the existence of other “crypto” coins muddies the scarcity water. Some may be hesitant on BTC’s portability given the difficulties that some exchanges have with other crypto currencies.

    But the end result is the same as for gold. It depends on a system that coalesces around its use as a vehicle to hold monetary value. There is naturally a small irony that Bitcoin’s value is stated in USD when its role is perceived to subvert these currencies.

    Where it can diverge from gold is if it finds a role in payments and finance rather than as a speculative asset. The recent sharp rise in the price and volatility undermines that status.

    Investors risk conflating a messy case on loss in sovereign currency value (due to debt issuance) with a created asset that has yet to prove its validity as a safer store of value. Bitcoin’s true potential may rather be in transactional power and movement of money. Whether this sits well with regulators and the inevitable undercurrent of undesirable activity remains to be seen. The outcome may well be some form of regulation or oversight which then takes crypto-currencies into the mainstream.

    Print Article

    Higher inflation, recession more likely: Franklin Templeton

    Late July news of the Federal Reserve (Fed) increasing interest rates another 0.75% and a second negative quarter of economic growth (GDP) has created an uncertain environment for investors going forward. Adding to these concerns is China’s economic slowdown and Europe’s energy shock.  Stephen Dover, Chief Market Strategist, at the Franklin Templeton Investment Institute presents…

    Stephen Dover | 15th Aug 2022 | More
    Jones looks to shorten exam, improve ethics code

    Once the Quality of Advice Review is done, the new financial services minister has asked Treasury to look at updating the Code of Ethics and assessing the viability of a shortened adviser exam.

    Tahn Sharpe | 15th Aug 2022 | More
    AZ NGA dives into supply chain with Virtual Business Partners tie-up

    The Italian-backed group has teamed up with one of AMP’s largest advice businesses to take a major stake in the back-office services provider. It’s the first time AZ NGA has ventured beyond advice and accounting investment.

    Tahn Sharpe | 15th Aug 2022 | More
    Advisers urged to tread carefully with ‘wholesale investor’ status
    Staff Writer | 28th Jul 2022 | More
    Top hedge fund award goes to L1 Capital
    Greg Bright | 13th Dec 2021 | More
    MAX Award winners and the new world outside
    Greg Bright | 13th Jun 2022 | More
    INDepth with Andrew Lockhart from Metrics Credit Partners
    The Inside Adviser | 30th Jun 2022 | More