Stay informed Sign up for our newsletter and be the first to know.
Stay informed Sign up for our newsletter and be the first to know.
Brilliant Investment Thinking by Advisers for Advisers.
ASX
-0.36%
S&P
-0.40%
AUD
$0.68

Asset Allocation

Share
Print

The hidden style bet inside the global index 

The hidden style bet inside the global index 
Share
Print

RQI Investors’ David Walsh argues that a market cap-weighted exposure to global equities has become a concentrated bet on a handful of expensive US stocks.

Buying a market cap-weighted index fund is usually seen as a clean route to diversification. David Walsh, head of investments at RQI Investors, argues that in developed market equities it has become something closer to a concentrated wager on a small group of expensive US technology stocks. 

His research identifies two fronts of concentration risk, market cap and style. The rise in index weight of the largest firms, led by the so-called Magnificent 7, largely reflects expectations for future business growth rather than growth already realised, leaving their stock prices increasingly dependent on meeting high earnings expectations. 

 A “diversified” exposure taken through an index fund or ETF may deliver a concentrated position in a small number of names, and a strong bet on expensive growth. 

“Market cap index exposure cannot ever really be considered ‘style neutral’, but we believe it is now an extreme style bet,” Walsh says. 

Measuring the problem 

The US share of the MSCI World index climbed from 49 per cent at the start of 2000 to 57 per cent in 2015. The share then reached 74 per cent by the end of 2024. It remains close to this level to the current day. The figure fell back to about 70% following the tech selloff in early 2026, then rebounded.

Australia’s share slipped back to 1.7 per cent by the end of 2024 and has shrunk further to 1.5% in the present day. This growth comes with increased concentration. The top 10 stocks in the MSCI World, all of them American, rose from about 10 per cent of the index in 2015 to around 27 per cent by the end of 2024 and remains near this level. The  benchmark contains roughly 1,400 companies. 

“Investors in benchmarks which supposedly get broad exposure to these equity markets are actually exposed to a small, concentrated and expensive set of stocks.”

Valuations compound the concentration. Currently, the top 10 names traded on an average price to earnings ratio of 29 times. That is down from 38 times at the beginning of 2025. Compare this against 28 times for all US stocks in the MSCI World. The figure is about 24 times for the index as a whole.

On forward earnings, the largest US stocks traded at around 22 times, an earnings yield of about 4.5 per cent, below the 4.6 per cent available on one-year US Treasury bills. This reflects sharply upgraded earnings expectations rather than a reduction in price. Because equity holders rank behind debt holders, shares should offer a premium over bonds. Comparing the two, Walsh finds no difference between them, a zero risk premium. 

The concentration also makes life difficult for traditional stock pickers, who find it difficult to beat the benchmark on total return without taking very concentrated positions. “There are simply too few stocks which will outperform on their own,” he notes. 

Closer to home 

Walsh is clear that the problem was a US phenomenon, but has become an issue in emerging markets as well. In follow-up studies of Australia and emerging markets, he found that the largest Australian stocks have not grown their share over time.  

The ASX 200 has always been highly concentrated, with the top 10 stocks taking up between 46 and 50 per cent of the benchmark over time. However, while the MSCI Emerging Markets index has traditionally been less concentrated, with the top 10 accounting for between 20 and 25 per cent over time, this has increased sharply to as much as 38% at the moment. 

RQI’s response is to remove price from the starting point altogether. The firm builds its core portfolio on the reported dollar value of a small set of accounting variables. Market cap plays no part in determining weights. “RQI’s approach to value investing deliberately avoids chasing this sort of concentration in market cap,” Walsh explains.  

RQI then layers on additional signals such as quality, momentum and sentiment. These favour businesses with stronger cash flows, sound management and more resilient business models. The approach sidesteps stocks that may cheap for a good reason.

The result is a far more stable profile. The top 10 stocks in RQI’s developed markets core have remained around 10 to 12 per cent of the portfolio. Meanwhile, their benchmark equivalents rose above 25 per cent.

Many of the same names appear, including Apple, Microsoft, Amazon and Meta. Their weights are more balanced and driven by company fundamentals. The portfolio holds more in lower valuation stocks beyond the top 10.

That core carried a forward earnings yield about 1.5 per cent above the MSCI World, although it has been wider. The equivalent spread was about 1 per cent in Australia and about 5 per cent in emerging markets, where the benchmark holds 14 per cent in TSMC compared with 4 per cent in the RQI core. 

Share
Print