Stay informed Sign up for our newsletter and be the first to know.
Stay informed Sign up for our newsletter and be the first to know.
Brilliant Investment Thinking by Advisers for Advisers.
ASX
-0.77%
S&P
-0.23%
AUD
$0.67

Compliance

Share
Print

Private credit: four questions advisers should ask when assessing a manager

Private credit: four questions advisers should ask when assessing a manager
Share
Print

Private credit covers a wide range of lending strategies with different assets, risks and liquidity, so four practical questions on holdings, governance, income and risk help advisers compare managers carefully and look beyond headline yield.

Private credit continues to attract investors seeking portfolio diversification and income. Its growth also means advisers now have a wider range of managers, strategies and product structures to assess.

Recent industry scrutiny has highlighted the importance of transparency, valuations, governance and product design. It has also reinforced the need to distinguish between private credit strategies, which can vary considerably in their underlying assets, security structures, sources of return and liquidity characteristics.

The term “private credit” covers a broad range of lending strategies. Assets, sources of return, security structures and liquidity risks can differ substantially from one fund to another. Comparing products on headline yield alone can therefore obscure important differences.

For advisers, the more useful question is not simply, “What return is being offered?” Rather, they should be asking: “How is that return generated, what are the associated risks and what evidence demonstrates the manager’s ability to deliver it consistently?”

Four practical questions can help advisers make that assessment.

What am I actually investing in?

One of the most important questions advisers can help clients answer is: “Do I clearly understand what I am investing in?”

Private credit strategies can differ significantly in their objectives, asset selection and risk profile. Some focus on development and construction lending, while others invest in established, income-producing mortgage assets secured by completed residential and commercial property.

Advisers need sufficient transparency to understand the underlying portfolio, how loans are originated and selected, and the risks being taken to generate the stated return. Portfolio composition, lending criteria, risk management practices and return drivers are all critical areas to assess.

Independent research ratings and regular reporting can provide additional insight into a manager’s investment approach, governance and performance history, although they should complement rather than replace appropriate due diligence.

Who makes the decisions and who provides oversight?

Strong governance is often a defining characteristic of a high-quality asset manager. However, governance is more than the experience of a management team. Advisers should understand how the manager approves loans, manages conflicts, values assets and handles arrears or impaired loans.

Investors should assess the leadership team’s experience, the quality of investment decision-making and the oversight arrangements that support accountability. Independent trustees, auditors, compliance programs and external service providers each play an important role in a governance framework designed to protect investor interests.

A manager’s track record can also provide valuable insight into how effectively these structures operate in practice.

For investors, strong governance provides confidence that the manager makes investment decisions consistently, monitors risks appropriately and keeps long-term objectives the priority.

Where does the income come from?

Yield is often one of the main attractions of private credit but understanding how that income is generated is equally important.

Different private credit strategies produce returns in different ways. Some rely on projects that may not generate cashflow until construction finishes or the manager sells assets. In these cases, future project outcomes and market conditions can heavily influence investment returns. Investors should generally expect compensation for taking on this additional uncertainty.

By comparison, portfolios backed by performing mortgage loans have the potential to generate recurring cashflow through regular borrower repayments. This creates a more direct connection between the underlying assets and investor distributions.

For investors seeking income, the quality, consistency and sustainability of underlying cashflows are often more important indicators than headline yield alone.

How are risk and liquidity managed?

Every investment involves risk. The key issue is whether those risks are clearly identified, appropriately priced and actively managed

A well-constructed private credit portfolio should demonstrate diversification across borrowers, loan exposures, property sectors and geographic regions. Investors should also consider factors such as loan-to-value ratios, security structures, borrower quality and exposure limits.

Liquidity management is another critical consideration. Advisers should understand how a fund manages cashflows, withdrawal requests and changing market conditions. A fund offering regular withdrawal windows should have a liquidity framework that is consistent with the maturity, repayment profile and marketability of its underlying assets.

A robust liquidity framework should match the nature of the underlying assets. It should support investors throughout different stages of the economic cycle.

Looking beyond headline returns

Private credit can play an important role in a diversified investment portfolio, but selecting the right manager requires more than comparing yields.

Advisors should look closely at four key areas: transparency, governance, income quality and risk / liquidity management. Managers that demonstrate strength across these fundamentals are generally better positioned to deliver consistent outcomes and navigate changing market conditions.

By looking beyond headline returns and understanding how a manager operates, advisors can make more informed decisions and build greater confidence in their private credit allocations.

Share
Print