Monday 16th November 2026
When delegation isn’t diligence: investment governance for Australian charities
Delegating the task of investing is not the same as delegating the duty to understand it and bear responsibility for it.
Every charity board that holds reserves faces the decision to manage the assets in house or engage external expertise of portfolio management services. Delegation of this function may be to parties that include a financial adviser, investment consultant, a managed fund or some other investment platform.
This instinct is not unreasonable. Most charity directors are volunteers, chosen for their passion for a cause or their professional skills in a field that might be unrelated, and not specifically for their expertise in asset allocation.
However, it is worthwhile noting that Australia’s current wave of investment governance reforms is delivering a pointed lesson to boards across every sector. Delegating the task of investing is not the same as delegating the duty to understand it and bear responsibility for it.
Wherever that distinction has been blurred, regulators are now finding failure, and charities are not immune.
A crisis born of misplaced trust
The immediate catalyst for Australia’s current governance reckoning is the collapse of the Shield Master Fund and First Guardian Master Fund. These two managed investment schemes together affected more than 11,000 investors and erased over $1 billion, much of it superannuation savings.
The pattern was strikingly consistent. People were cold-called, encouraged to roll their super into self-managed super funds, and steered into these schemes by advisers who often stood to benefit from the referral.
Significant conflicts of interest were later uncovered in how the funds were managed.
What has made this collapse a watershed moment, rather than an isolated scandal, is the response from regulators.
The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has commenced civil penalty proceedings against Trustees/ Responsible Entities alleging failures of care, skill and diligence in permitting members to invest in these products.
Furthermore, in March 2026, the Federal Court found a fund manager to be in contravention of the Corporations Act. It did so simply by failing to place the Shield fund on a watch list, despite clear warning signs.
These industry developments highlight that Trustees (in the case of Shield/ First Guardian) or Boards/ Investment Committees (in the case of not-for-profits), whilst having a ‘process’ in place, may not always understand the effectiveness of that framework. That includes the importance of ongoing monitoring long after they have onboarded investments.
This is the crux of the delegation-versus-diligence problem, and it extends beyond any particular industry segment. In fact, any NFP organisation (charity, foundation, or endowment), charged with investment decision making, that places funds with an external manager faces the identical question. A court or regulator may eventually ask:
“Did you understand what you approved, or did you simply delegate trust and responsibility to another party”?
The ACNC’s guidance for charities
Recognising this risk, the Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission (ACNC) released new guidance in April 2026 aimed specifically at charities holding cash reserves.
Summing up the implications of low investment governance: a poor investment decision can impair a charity’s ability to fulfil the very purpose it exists to serve.
The ACNC’s guidance sets out expectations that amount to a practical test of genuine diligence, not mere delegation.
A documented investment policy
A charity should be able to show, in writing, what it decided to invest in, why, and within what risk parameters, not simply point to an external manager’s recommendation after the fact.
Diligent record-keeping
Boards must be able to demonstrate how and why a decision was made, not just that a particular return was achieved.
Ongoing risk management
Investment decisions require periodic review, not a “set and forget” mentality once a manager or platform has been engaged.
Scrutiny of private benefit and related-party risk
Because a charity’s purposes must be for public benefit, any private benefit arising from an investment, including a related-party arrangement, must be transparent and there should be no actual or perceived conflicts of interest.
The above target points sit squarely within the ACNC’s broader 2026–27 regulatory focus areas. These areas flag concern that many charities’ constitutions, rules and trust deeds are outdated. They also flag concern that many charities understand them poorly. It drives home the message that boards remain accountable for risks embedded in partnership and financial arrangements. That includes relationships with external investment advisers/ managers.
Why charities are particularly exposed
ASIC’s 2026 key issues outlook identifies a system-wide concern that should get increasing attention from Charities/ NFPs;
“Retail access to private credit and other private market products is expanding rapidly, with investment thresholds now as low as approx. $2,000, and platforms increasingly enabling participation in products that are inherently less transparent and more complex.”
ASIC has also warned about aggressive marketing, lead-generation practices, and “cookie-cutter” advice models that push people into investments unsuited to their circumstances.
For a charity, this risk is not merely present. It is amplified.
On average, NFPs managing reserves/ investment portfolios are often no more sophisticated an investor than the retail consumer ASIC is describing. Boards can be just as susceptible to a compelling yield pitch, particularly when reserves have languished in low-interest cash accounts.
However, the consequences of getting it wrong for a charity board focuses the spotlight on funds held on trust for a public purpose, with all the reputational and regulatory fallout that follows. That fallout lands not on the external party engaged, but on the board that rubber-stamped the approvals.
Key takeaways for NFPs and charities
The reform wave now moving through the Australian investments industry (including NFPs and charities) carries a message that applies with equal force to all boards and investment committees.
A governing body cannot outsource judgment along with implementation.
Engaging an adviser or appointing an external manager remains entirely legitimate, indeed often prudent. But it does not discharge a board’s duty to understand, monitor, and be able to explain the decisions made in its name.
The ACNC’s new guidance effectively puts charities on formal notice of this expectation.
Some boards continue to treat investment governance as a box they tick once, rather than a responsibility they exercise continuously. Those boards are increasingly out of step with where regulators, and the courts, are heading.
Delegation may lighten the workload. It does not, and never has, discharged the duty of diligence.