Home / ESG / Markets grow “irrationally enthusiastic” for ESG

Markets grow “irrationally enthusiastic” for ESG


Markets are experiencing a “manic moment” around ESG investments and less exuberance now might not be “a bad thing in the longer run”, according to Fidelity investment director Tom Stevenson.

Stevenson likens the obsession with ESG to the popularity of the “Nifty 50” – stocks like Kodak, IBM and Xerox – in the 1970s and the dotcom bubble of the late 1990s and warns that while the story underlying the ESG narrative “is completely plausible”, it may not be enough to overcome the market’s “law of gravity”.

“(Share prices) are determined firstly by expectations about future earnings growth and secondly by the price that investors are prepared to pay to participate in that growth. That sounds simple,” Stevenson writes. “It is complicated, however, both by the fact that the future is inherently uncertain, so we are always guessing what that future growth will be and when it will arrive, and by the ever-shifting calculus about what constitutes a reasonable valuation.”

That uncertainty is compounded by the weight of money chasing returns in the ESG space, which Stevenson believes is distorting fundamentals by driving prices higher in the short-term. There is now US$40 trillion invested in ESG assets, and with the pace of accumulation increasing in line with outflows in the broader fund universe, ESG performance has become “self-fulfilling”.

“The underlying narrative is only part of the story from an investor’s perspective. There are plenty of good reasons to consider environmental, social and governance factors when we decide where to invest our money. But unless you place yourself firmly at the philanthropic end of the investment spectrum, none of them are reasons to disregard the fundamental factors that drive returns.”

Stevenson doesn’t dispute that the primary driver of ESG’s success – potentially exponential growth in the face of burgeoning environmental and social issues  – but says that there is a “burning need” to rationalise how to describe ESG investments in order to pick long-term winners from losers.

“That ESG should have started to be talked about as a potential stock market bubble is disappointing,” Stevenson writes. “I report it through gritted teeth because I defer to no-one in my desire for a world in which companies manage themselves honestly and prudently, are concerned for the health of the planet, and look out for the well-being of their employees, suppliers and customers. I think that what we do with our money matters.”

Print Article

A great way to play the booming natural gas market

Longreach taps into the LNG market supported by projects in Texas & Oklahoma.

Ishan Dan | 11th Aug 2022 | More
ASIC levy review targets adviser ‘time-lag’ issue

The review will consider “the consequences of time lags between regulatory action and cost allocation”, the terms of reference states.

Tahn Sharpe | 11th Aug 2022 | More
AMP Advice to ‘break even’ by 2024 as losses soften

The institutional provider’s AUM and profit lines stayed red in 1H22, but positive signs emerged.

Tahn Sharpe | 11th Aug 2022 | More
Advisers urged to tread carefully with ‘wholesale investor’ status
Staff Writer | 28th Jul 2022 | More
Top hedge fund award goes to L1 Capital
Greg Bright | 13th Dec 2021 | More
MAX Award winners and the new world outside
Greg Bright | 13th Jun 2022 | More
INDepth with Andrew Lockhart from Metrics Credit Partners
The Inside Adviser | 30th Jun 2022 | More
Quality of advice review focused on advisers, not consumers
Drew Meredith | 11th Jul 2022 | More